Saturday, October 26, 2013

NATURE DEFICIT DISORDER: A PROBLEM OF THE 21ST CENTURY


Thanks are due to my dear friend and colleague Füsun Savcı for this wonderful post
The 21st century with its tower blocks and rapidly disappearing countryside has given rise to a grave new problem: nature deficit disorder, which wreaks havoc with one’s quality of life and shortens one’s life span. Familiarize yourself with the problem via the link below, read up on it, watch the suggested videos and write an essay analyzing the causes and suggesting solutions.
Familiarize yourself with the problem by studying the link below:
Reading material to annotate:
1.       “Do Trees on Streets Make People Happy?”  By: Vanessa Barford http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-11889768
2.       “Back to Nature: Understanding ‘Nature Deficit Disorder’” By: Network Ireland http://networkmagazine.ie/articles/back-nature-understanding-nature-deficit-disorder
3.       “Decline of the Biology Nerds” By: Nessa Carrey, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/nessa-carey/science-education_b_3792091.html
4.       “Analysis: Animals Can Help Tackle Nature Deficit” By: Chris West http://www.scotsman.com/news/analysis-animals-can-help-tackle-nature-deficit-1-3008889
Videos to watch and take notes from:
1.       “Videos about Last Child in the Woods” http://richardlouv.com/books/last-child/videos/

2.       “Nature Deficit Disorder” http://science.kqed.org/quest/video/nature-deficit-disorder/
       
       Refer to my second blog, The Essay Archive, for sample essays: https://theessayarchive.blogspot.com.tr/  

Thursday, October 24, 2013

CAUSE / EFFECT ESSAY: WHY DO WE PLAY GAMES?


Thanks are due to my dear friend and fellow teacher Pınar Pekel and her student Ege Aygıt (Advanced B, fall 2013) for this brilliant post
Games are enjoyed by one and all and always have been yet at first glance, they seem to serve no practical purpose. Children love playing all manner of structured or unstructured games, adults play sports, board games and video games but why do they do it? Do your research and discover the reasons and then write an essay discussing the causes.
Reading material to annotate:
Video to watch and make notes on

1.       “Why do we play games” http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e5jDspIC     
        
      Refer to my second blog, The Essay Archive, for sample essays: https://theessayarchive.blogspot.com.tr/  


Wednesday, October 23, 2013

COMPARISON / CONTRAST ESSAY: ELECTORAL SYSTEMS


The purpose of this essay task is to show you how fluid the lines between various ‘essay types’ are: you will be able to use classification structures, comparison contrast structures and write an argumentative essay as well. The reason is that not having a reason for comparison is not an option and what better reason than a personal preference? What better method of supporting your view than a comparison?
I.                    Introduction: Democracy has always been defined as the government of the people by the people, and an integral part of any democratic process is the elections during which the people vote freely for people to represent them in parliament and govern them in their stead. This is the principle but there are various different electoral systems which can be classified in different ways. Two of these systems are the absolute majority system, and the system of proportional representation; both are examples of ‘multiple winner models’ yet which is more appropriate for your home country is a matter of debate. Thesis statement here: state clearly which method you think is more appropriate for your home country and compare and contrast them in your development to justify your choice.
II.                  Development: In order to write your essay, you will need to research the merits and demerits of the two systems mentioned in the introduction. Once you have completed your reading, you will need to decide how to organize the development. Read and annotate the reading material suggested below:
1.       “Multiple Winner Models” http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_system#Multiple-winner_methods
2.       “Proportional Representation” http://www.historylearningsite.co.uk/proportional_representation.htm
3.       “Democracy Building: Elections Voting Systems” http://www.democracy-building.info/voting-systems.html
4.       “Pros and Cons of Proportional Representation”http://www.tellmehowto.net/howto/pros_and_cons_of_proportional_representation_8707
5.       “First Past the Post” http://www.electoral-reform.org.uk/first-past-the-post/
Suggested Plan for the Development: It is suggested that you compare the two systems in terms of "their effects on the electoral system" in the first paragraph of your development and in terms of "their effects on the outcome of the election" in the second paragraph of your development. In your first developmental paragraph, you could compare them interms of how representative and democratic each is and in your second developmental paragraph, you could compare them in terms of the kind of governments they produce. 
III.   Conclusion: Write a restatement


Refer to my second blog, The Essay Archive, for sample essays: https://theessayarchive.blogspot.com.tr/  


Tuesday, October 22, 2013

CLASSIFICATION / COMPARISON CONTRAST ESSAY: PAINTERS


The purpose of this writing task is to draw your attention to the close relationship between classification and comparison / contrast essays. You will need to use structures you learnt when studying both to complete your essay. Read the introduction to an essay classifying painters below, which you can use, do your research and complete the essay:
I.Introduction:
The desire to portray events and depict the world around in the form of visual art dates back to the cave paintings in France and the rock paintings of the Aborigines. Since that time, many gifted individuals have provided humanity with immortal masterpieces that we enjoy hundreds of years after their creation. We still appreciate Picasso’s Guernica, Van Gogh’s Sunflowers and Leonardo’s Mona Lisa – or La Giaconda – and we will continue to do so. Yet there are many different kinds of painters and they can be classified in many different ways two of which are the school of painting they belong to and their subject matter.
II. First developmental paragraph:
Criterion: the school of painting
Examples: the Impressionists, the Expressionists, Cubic Painters
Points to compare and contrast: you will need to do your research to discover these points.
Websites:  
The Impressionists:
The Expressionists:
Cubic Painters:

III. Second developmental paragraph:
Criterion: subject matter – portrait, landscape, still-life, abstract and the like.
Examples: Jonathan Yeo, John Constable, George Claire
Points to compare and contrast: you will need to do your research to discover these points.
Websites:
Jonathan Yeo
John Constable:
George Claire:
IV. Conclusion:
In your conclusion, discuss the importance of painting in adding colour to our lives and contributing to happiness. Seeking beauty is an inherent feature of human beings

Refer to my second blog, The Essay Archive, for sample essays: https://theessayarchive.blogspot.com.tr/  






Monday, October 21, 2013

SMART ROBOTS, DRIVERLESS CARS WORK – BUT THEY BRING ETHICAL ISSUES TOO


“Educational robots, intelligent implants, brain chips: scientists and legal experts will meet this week to debate how to deal with the rapid march of technology”
By: Nicola Davis
Published: The Observer, 20 October 2013; http://observer.theguardian.com/ Alternatively, just google the title and writer’s name.
Level of difficulty: **
BEFORE YOU READ
  • Turn to the end of the text and look at the 'Future Questions’. Discuss them with your classmates or read them carefully and think about them.
  • Now skim the text quickly and place the subtitles listed below in their correct places. The answer key will follow the print version of the text. The subtitles are in the correct order: Introduction, IBM’s Intelligent System: Watson, Driverless Cars, Enhanced Body Parts, Social Robots, Conclusion
NOW CHECK OUT THE FOLLOWING VIDEOS
 Ethics and robotics
The ethics of robotics
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NoPxP5G44Rk
QUESTIONS
  1. What lead to the need for the ‘EUCogIII members’ conference?
  2. What does the phrase “if we get it wrong” mean?
  3. What advantages does Watson have over a living, breathing doctor?
  4. What is the dilemma concerning Watson?
  5. How could the drawbacks of such a healthcare system be minimized?
  6. Driverless cars seem like the solution to many current problems yet people are worried. Why?
  7. How could both drivers and car companies be protected against problems of malfunction?
  8. What current law would become meaningless when driverless cars hit the market?
  9. Why might individuals wish to replace their perfectly healthy legs and arms with prosthetic devices?
  10. What does “it” refer to in the phrase “and yes, it’s a problem”?
  11. The writer says “Running scared is not an option”. Why would some people want to run scared?
  12. What interesting discovery was made concerning social robots in education?
  13. The scientists involved in the upcoming convention have invited the public to join the discussion. Why have they taken this step?
WRITING TASK
Write an essay in which you discuss the advantages and disadvantages of “the rapid march of artificial intelligence”. Consider the advantages and disadvantages below and use notes you make on the text to provide support.
Advantages
  • Saving time and effort
  • Accuracy
Disadvantages
  • Security concerns
  • Legal issues
SMART ROBOTS, DRIVERLESS CARS WORK – BUT THEY BRING ETHICAL ISSUES TOO KEY AND TEACHER’S NOTES.
This text introduces a completely new dilemma: the lure of modern artificial intelligence in the shape of various different kinds of high functioning robots and implants versus the dangers they pose. New developments in artificial intelligence are coming at us thick and fast and we, as a species, need to deal with the implications. The discussion of future moral quandaries at the end of the text should be interesting and revealing. The points given for the essay task will need to be supported with information from the text.
BEFORE YOU READ: SUBTITLES
Introduction: paragraphs 1+2; Watson: p.3, 4, 5, 6+7; Driverless Cars: p.8, 9 +10; Enhanced Body Parts: p. 11, 12, 13 +14; Social Robots: 15+16; Conclusion: 17+18
QUESTIONS / KEY
  1. The fact that artificial intelligence is poised to revolutionize our lives
  2. If we make the wrong decisions concerning the ethical and societal impact of such systems
  3. It can crunch through swaths of medical information and make decisions; it could suggest an accurate diagnosis faster and more often, as well as predicting an individual’s health risks.
  4. Whether we want to give up some of our privacy in order to get improved services like better health care.
  5. By making it essential that doctors are closely involved in training such systems, understanding how they work and confirming the diagnoses are spot on.
  6. Insurance and legislation
  7. Through the usage of compulsory insurance schemes or by assessing so called safe harbors. The rest is not necessary.
  8. Speed limits
  9. Because they could outperform our natural limbs
  10. The fact that technology is moving faster than technology can keep up
  11. Because with the possibility of technology becoming intertwined with our very bodies, the threat of unauthorized access looms large.
  12. Robots sporting a face and personalized conversation evoke a strong response
  13. Because such technological leaps are set to transform our lives.




Sunday, October 20, 2013

CLASSIFICATION ESSAY: NON GOVERMENTAL ORGANIZATIONS OR NGO'S


There are a lot of organizations in the world whose only aim is to help, support and preserve with no view to making a profit and no connections to governments which do a lot of good. These organizations, termed non-governmental organizations or NGO’S, are many and varied. Write an essay in which you classify International NGO’s. Naturally, you will need to do some research first.
In your introduction, discuss NGO’s in general and end with a thesis statement indicating a classification according to purpose. Make notes on the link below to be able to write your introduction:
In your first developmental paragraph, discuss NGO’s whose focus is health care. In this context, focus on a few examples and discuss what they do and how. It is suggested that you focus on Doctors without Borders or MSF and the International Red Cross. You will be able to further classify these NGO’s according to their specific area of focus / interest or the extent of their remit – a wider remit, a more limited remit. Use the links below:
In your second developmental paragraph, discuss NGO’s that focus on the protection of rights. It is suggested you focus on Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International, PRI and The Walk Free Foundation. You will be able to further classify these NGO’s according to their specific area of focus / interest or the extent of their remit – a wider remit, a more limited remit.  Use the links below:
In your third developmental paragraph, discuss NGO’s that focus on conservation. It is suggested that you focus on Greenpeace, Friends of The Earth and The Sea Shepherds. You will be able to further classify these NGO’s according to their specific area of focus / interest or the extent of their remit – a wider remit, a more limited remit. Use the links below:
In your conclusion, discuss the importance of the work such organizations do.


Refer to my second blog, The Essay Archive, for sample essays: https://theessayarchive.blogspot.com.tr/  


Friday, October 18, 2013

HARD WIRED FOR GIVING


“Contrary to conventional wisdom that humans are essentially selfish,scientists are finding that the brain is built for generosity”
By: Elizabeth Svoboda
Published: The Wall Street Journal, The Saturday Essay, August 31, 2013, www.wsj.com Alternatively, google the title and writer’s name.
Level of Difficulty: ***
BEFORE YOU READ
·        Generosity https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EOUnMNWKuJI 
QUESTIONS
1.       What view is supported by Darwinism and economic theory but not completely by the latest science?
2.       What does “This” refer to in the phrase “This represents a new scientific frontier”?
3.       In attempting to explain altruism, scientists linked the feeling to
·         A form of selfishness
·          Family protection
·         Social welbeing
·         All of the above
·         None of the above
·         Other : please specify
4.       The veterans Dr. Grafman studied in the 1980’s seemed to have the lost the feelings of ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………
5.       Read Dr. Grafman’s study with 19 subjects carefully. What important observation was made during the experiment? What conclusion can we draw from this experiment?
6.       What was the second important finding made during the experiment and what conclusion can we draw from it?
7.       How did Dr. Grafman reach the conclusion that the anterior prefrontal cortex is affective in complex judgements and decision making?
8.       Read Bill Harbaugh’s experiment carefully to the end. Now answer the following questions:
·         At the beginning, the researcher decided that people engage in altruistic behavior because…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..
·         Was this view proved, partially proved or disproved by experiments with the MRI scanner?
·         In what respect did the observations made during the experiment correspond to Dr. Grafman’s?
·         How does the above observation impact real life decision making?
9.       According to what criterium did Dr. Harbaugh categorize people?
10.   Why could some people be categorized as “dedicated altruists”?
11.   Read the paragraph beginning “On balance…” carefully. Which of the following statements is / are true according to this paragraph?
·         We don’t often come across pure altruism.
·         We can never be sure that an act of generosity is purely altruistic.
·         Level of self satisfaction is not linked to altruism
·         All of the above
·         None of the above
·         Other: please specify
12.   What does “this technique” in the phrase “using this techniques” refer to?
13.   Dr. Deisseroth’s experiments proved that behaviour modification is possible / isn’t possible.
14.   Linking generosity solely to biological factors is a mistake because ……………………………are/is overlooked.
15.   Dr. Harbaugh has a possible answer to the issue of increasing generosity. It is…………………….
WRITING TASK
Use the information you gleaned from the text and the suggested plan below to write an essay in which you discuss the reasons why people act generously.
In your introduction, introduce the concept of communal living  and the values upheld in society. Introduce generosity as one of these desirable characteristics and explain what it entails. End with a thesis statement in which you state there are three categories of reasons for generosity.
In the first developmental paragraph, discuss the biological explanation. Explain that we feel actual pleasure as a result of generosity. Refer to the text.
In your second developmental paragraraph, discuss environmental influences: looking good, gaining social leverage, helping individuals improve their prospects by contributing to the welbeing of a strong collective(text).Give examples.
In your third developmental paragraph, discuss individual initiative: ensuring the survival of kin, pure altruism. Give examples.
In your conclusion, explain that generosity is highly desirable and that people can be made more generous. Refer to the text.
HARD WIRED FOR GIVING KEY AND TEACHER’S NOTES
It is very rare that I am able to find a text which is written in such a way that serious careful reading questions become possible. This is one such text. The Saturday essays in the Wall Street Journal are always a treasure trove but this is a little gem because it is interesting, well written and has all the twists and turns someone writing questions loves to see. The bonus is that there is a brilliant writing task to follow.
1.       Survival of the fittest or the self centered theory
2.       Biological hardware that makes altruism possible
3.       All of the above
4.       Generosity and empathy (= caring what other people had to say)
5.       When people made the decision to donate to what they felt was a worthy organization,parts of the midbrain, the same region that controls cravings for food and sex… ; giving is actually inherently rewarding (the rest is optional).
6.       The subgenual area was also strongly active when his study subjects made the decision to give to charity; altruism and social relations are intimitaly connected.
7.       This area lit up when the subjects were willing to give even when they knew it would cost them
8.       They expect some tangible reward; partially proved( the econ 101 model still stood but it was no longer the only reason: the biological reason was also valid);similar observations were made concerning the area of the brain that was active or a similar phrase; people give to charity not only because they think it is a good thing to do but also because giving makes them feel good.
9.       According to their amount of nucleus accumbens activation. The next sentence is what the doctor surmised.
10.   They were willing to give because they knew it would help others even if giving didn’t make them feel all that great.
11.   1 and 2
12.   Activating and deactivating the cells by snaking an optical fiber into a mouse’s brain and turning on the light. You might want to stop and discuss or think about this and wether it should be applied to humans
13.   Is possible
14.   Environmental influences and individual initiative
15.   Giving relatively small amounts of money to charity to start with…